Adaptive integration of hardware and software lock elision techniques

Transactional Lock Elision (TLE) and optimistic software execution can both improve scalability of lock-based programs. The former uses hardware transactional memory (HTM) without requiring code changes; the latter involves modest code changes but does not require special hardware support. Numerous factors affect the choice of technique, including: critical section code, calling context, workload characteristics, and hardware support for synchronization. The ALE library integrates these techniques, and collects detailed, fine-grained performance data, enabling policies that decide between them at runtime for each critical section execution. We describe an adaptive policy and present experiments on three platforms, two of which support HTM, showing that---without tuning for specific platforms or workload---the adaptive policy is competitive with and often significantly better than hand-tuned static policies.